Measure 6: Best Interests of the Child vs. Rights of the Parent?

Measure 6 is a current initiative, which if approved, would create a legal presumption that each parent in a child custody case is fit to parent and that a requesting parent should receive equal residential responsibility.  That artificial presumption of fitness as a parent could only be rebutted upon a showing by clear and convincing evidence.  A burden of proof higher than that needed to win a civil trial for negligence—only slightly below the burden required to convict someone of a crime—and is typically associated with the proof needed for the State to terminate parental rights in the most extreme cases…Currently in North Dakota the law requires that parenting rights and responsibilities be determined by analyzing 13 best interest factors and weighing those factors as they apply to each parent.  These factors include the ability of each parent to provide for the child, the sufficiency and stability of each parent’s home environment, the mental and physical heath of each of the parents as it impacts the child, as well as other factors.  The purpose of the law as it stands is to determine what is in the best interests of the child through analysis of the best interest factors.

With Measure 6, there would be an artificial presumption that equal residential responsibility is in the best interest of the child.  While equal residential responsibility may be best for the child in some cases, that is certainly not true across the board and in every case.  Each situation is unique.  Each child is unique.  The effect of Measure 6 will likely be to encourage a mud-slinging contest between the two parents trying to prove the other is “unfit.”  This will not only involve matters that are incredibly personal, but difficult to prove in a courtroom.

Another issue with Measure 6 is the lack of definition regarding what exactly constitutes a fit or an unfit parent.  The consequence of this ambiguity will likely be substantial litigation while attorneys and judges attempt to decipher the meaning of these terms.  While the litigation unravels, the children will continue to be caught in the turmoil of their two parents’ quest for the other’s “unfitness.”  The perhaps well-meaning, idealistic legislation ultimately creates impractical, undesirable results.

Currently, if the court believes equal residential responsibility is in the best interests of the child, they order exactly that.  As it stands today, the Court is not bound by an artificial presumption mandating equal residential responsibility, but Measure 6—if passed—would change that.  Passage of Measure 6 would take away what’s best for the children and instead create an artificial standard regarding parents’ capabilities unless clear and convincing evidence is presented to rebut the contrary.

In conclusion, the current law in North Dakota focuses on the best interests of the child; this focus allows the courts to apply those 13 factors to determine if it’s in the child’s best interest to be with the mother, father, or if an equal residential responsibility situation is appropriate.  Starting out with the artificial presumption that equal residential responsibility is appropriate solely because each parent is “fit” is not necessarily what is in the child’s best interest.

-Kristin Redmann

Recent Posts

Leaker of nude photo identified; Cass County sheriff puts reserve deputy on leave

By April Baumgarten “I believe that I was put on admin leave to make me shut up," said the Cass County reserve deputy who sent a censored version of a lieutenant's nude photo to news outlets. “I think it was an example of what happens when people talk out and speak...

Legal expert weighs in on deadly shooting of Mapleton man by officers

By Bailey Hurley MAPLETON, N.D. (Valley News Live) - One legal expert and former police officer is weighing in on what’s next in the long review process of Monday’s shooting by four Fargo officers which killed a Mapleton man. The four officers have been placed on paid...

Major ruling leaves questions for tribal-land prosecutions in North Dakota

By Jack Dura Tribal nations sharing geography with North Dakota are watching for how the state will handle certain prosecutions after a major U.S. Supreme Court ruling impacting jurisdiction. The court ruled 5-4 in June that Oklahoma can prosecute non-Native Americans...

Fired police sergeant reaches settlement with Bismarck; amount not immediately disclosed

Parties have reached a settlement in a federal lawsuit brought by a former Bismarck police sergeant who alleged gender discrimination and wrongful termination against the department and its former chief. The agreement between Robyn Krile and the Bismarck Police...

Former Highway Patrol Trooper To Plead In Sex Assault Case

BISMARCK, N.D. (AP) — A former high-ranking North Dakota Highway Patrol trooper accused of sexual assault has agreed to a plea deal. Steven Johnson was charged in November with misdemeanor sexual assault after a woman accused of him of touching her inappropriately...

What’s a Giglio file? Police Officer Credibility & Your Rights.

Prosecutors, Police, and Defense Attorneys often talk about a "Giglio File" or a particular officer having "Giglio Issues." The term "Giglio," pronounced gig-leo, comes from the landmark U.S. Supreme Court cases Giglio v. United States, 405 U.S. 150 (1972) and Brady...

What to Expect When You’re Suspected of DUI

Most DUI arrests are the product of a police traffic stop.  Police need "reasonable suspicion" of a violation to stop or detain you; even the smallest violation will allow the police to stop you.  For example, around "bar close" many officers in Bismarck, Mandan, and...

The DOT Work Permit

If your license is suspended, all is not lost.  Most people are eligible for a work permit (aka restricted license) after 14 days of hard suspension if you’re on 24/7.  If you’re not on 24/7 you’re usually eligible for a work permit on a 1st DUI/Refusal offense within...

“A New Age Of Searching Student Cell Phones?”

North Dakota: The current state of cell phone searches in the school setting post-Riley SCHOOL OFFICIALS School searches by administrators must meet a two-part test. First, the search must be justified by reasonable suspicion at its inception. Second, the search must...

Attorney Methodology

Every case begins with a thorough client interview and consultation during which case goals, expectations, and rapport is established. The next step is the investigation stage as the best defense is a great offense. Every possible document, video, note, report, and...




107 1st Ave NW, Mandan, ND 58554, United States

Office Hours

9:00 am – 5:00 pm Monday thru Thursday

9:00 am – 12:00 pm Friday


(701) 751-7188